Close Menu
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
    CNQ
    • Issues
      • Number 114
      • Number 113
      • Number 112
      • Number 111
      • Number 110
      • Number 109
      • Number 108
      • Number 107
      • Number 106
      • Number 105
      • Number 104
      • Number 103
      • Number 102
      • Archive
    • Magazine
      • About
      • Contests
      • Advertise
      • Submissions
      • Where to Buy
      • Subscribe
      • Promotional Subscriptions
      • Contact
    • Features
      • Web Exclusive
      • Essays
        • CanLitCrit Essay Contest
      • Interviews
      • Reviews
      • CNQ Abroad
      • Poetry
      • Short Fiction
      • The North Wing
      • The Dusty Bookcase
      • Profiles in Bookselling
      • Used and Rare
    CNQ

    David Chariandy’s Brother
    Reviewed by Emily Donaldson

    0
    By CNQ Team on May 1, 2018 Reviews
    Brother
    by David Chariandy
    McClelland & Stewart, 180 pages.

    In the violence-prone suburban Toronto housing complex that serves as the setting for David Chariandy’s Writers’ Trust Prize-winning novel, the clustered, grim towers and low-rises—with names like the Waldorf, the Oberlin, the Rosedale—stand as mocking facsimile of a distant, glamorous world. The complex itself, a concrete jungle home to working-class immigrants from around the globe, is known as “the Park”; its local store, “Heritage Value” Convenience, is “run by that asshole who framed his useless foreign degree, despised the dark, stinking guts of every other immigrant.”

    That sense of a parallel, fringe-dwelling world stays with us throughout the novel. A city’s suburbs are by definition on its outskirts, but what we feel in the Scarborough of Brother is the connotive dig of the prefix “sub”: lesser than, subordinate. The “dull purple” sky that hangs over the Park is “the wasted light of a city.” Here, the sun arrives as plate-scrapings.

    The novel’s characters also exist, needless to say, on the periphery. You couldn’t say they’re on the outside looking in since the inside—mainstream white society—is barely referred to or glimpsed; except, perhaps, in the cops, “cold-eyed with purpose,” who, after a spate of shootings, undertake regular, intimidating sweeps of the neighbourhood. One of the few to escape is Aisha, an ex-girlfriend of the narrator who went to Montreal on a scholarship and is referred to by local parents as “the exception”; proving, of course, the rule.

    Growing up in the Park in the eighties, Francis has always been protector to Michael, vulnerable because he possesses none of his older brother’s traits. Francis is street-smart, devastatingly handsome, tough-as-nails; when threatened with a knife, he grabs it by the blade. In his later teens, though, he gets swept up in the burgeoning hip-hop DJ scene based out of a mall barbershop and starts to distance himself from Michael and their black Trinidadian mother, Ruth, who works unpredictable and long hours as a cleaner. (Their father, a brown man from the West Indies, left when the boys were small but is rumoured to live nearby.) Soon after, Francis is shot and killed by police.

    Brother alternates between the lead-up to this event and a point ten years later, with Michael in his twenties working a go-nowhere job at a grocery store so he can care for Ruth, now suffering dementia-like symptoms brought on by grief.

    Francis and Michael’s relationship is the novel’s ostensible focus, but Marlon James’ declaration, on the front-cover blurb, that it’s an “elegy from a living brother to a lost one” doesn’t sit quite right. Brother lacks the basic qualities of an elegy, being neither a lament nor poetic—which is not to say Chariandy’s spare, finely calibrated prose isn’t impressive. And Francis is mostly a cipher. We know him through his actions, glean a secret that will complicate his life regardless of how tough he is, but we don’t really know him. Don’t, by extension, feel Ruth’s pain when he dies.

    What Brother is really “about,” in its appealingly slant way, is the larger historical forces that led to this particular death, one among many. In the eyes of his neighbourhood, older Michael is “a brother carrying history.” That history is recent, but it’s also, we come to see, very old.

    It’s also about origins, and the consequences when our ties to them—cultural, familial—are disrupted. For Michael, the black-and-white photos of relatives scattered around the apartment are “ghostly images that were supposed to explain our eyes and way of smiling, our hair and bones”; Trinidad the place that “accounted for the presence in our house of certain drinks like mauby and sorrel and also the inexplicably named Peardrax, which Francis had once fooled me into believing was bathroom cleanser.”

    (Cleaning products are a bit of a theme. Next to and deep below the Park is the Rouge Valley, a “wound in the earth” where Michael and Francis go to escape the Park’s hard reality, and which functions, with its Lethe-like creek, as a kind of underworld in reverse. There, in a moment of pathos-infused comedy, Ruth holds a sprig of pine under young Francis’ nose. “Mr Clean!” he proudly announces.)

    Creating connections is part of hip hop’s appeal to Francis and his crew. Cannibalizing their parents’ record collections for samples, they start to see the latter and their music in a new, even admiring light; in this world, the DJ is bridge-builder, his aim to find the common beat to unite these musical fragments into a coherent whole.

    In his dive into hip-hop culture and elsewhere, Chariandy resists exposition. Instead he gestures, juxtaposes, borrows from his narrative environment, which is why Brother, for the most part, succeeds where many novels with similar aims fail. On the first page, Francis leads Michael up a hydro pole, promising the dangers will be worth the risk: “All that free air and seeing. The streets below suddenly patterns you could read.” The scene is echoed at the end of the book, when Michael, visiting Ruth in the hospital, encounters a boy who broke his collarbone falling off the roof of a building, and who, when asked why he did so, answers “To see.” These bookended descriptions express the need for distance and for perspective far better than any dialogue could.

    Though Ruth often seems to be in the background, Brother might just as well have been called Mother, so central is she to the novel’s heart. Its most moving section, Michael’s account of the sole trip he and Francis took with her to Trinidad when they were little, provides a first, albeit indirect glimpse into her mind. There, snippets of overheard conversation make it apparent to Michael that his mother has not told their relatives that their father left years ago, that in Canada they are neither wealthy nor comfortable. The weight of her unspoken pride and pain makes clear, moreover, that she will not do so.

    There too, the brothers see “billions of stars, the universe we had never imagined.” But they also discover, in a kind of colonial inversion of Foster’s Marabar caves, a shapeless new fear: “Something old and unburied in the darkness, something closer to us now than ever before.” A little further on, a kind of collision:

    What was this place in origins we had come to? In the years to come, Francis and I would hear the words slavery and indenture. We’d learn that the Caribbean was named after people who’d been pushed by murder and disease to the very brink of oblivion. But what of these histories could we read in the land we saw as children? Around us were wasted farmlands and abandoned cane fields, punctuated by what looked like shacks. We heard our poor black relatives speak of coolies, our poor Indian relatives speak of niggers, and both sides huff laughter at the “the Carib woman,” our distant relative, who sold green seasoning at the market and was obviously half-mad.

    “What is a mother’s dream of land?” asks Michael at one point. It’s an interesting twist on a familiar question: a mother is supposed to have dreams for her children, not “of land.” But other than a brief mention of a nursing degree scuttled by a lack of funds, the only proof Ruth harboured dreams of any kind is her very presence in the cold country to which she migrated so long ago. And here, perhaps, is part of Chariandy’s point: that answers rarely come without questions.

    —From CNQ 101, Winter 2018

    Related Posts

    Jana Prikryl’s Midwood
    by Andreae Callanan

    Tolu Oloruntoba’s Each One a Furnace
    by Kevin Spenst

    Madhur Anand’s Parasitic Oscillations
    by Shani Mootoo

    Comments are closed.


    CNQ Issue 114:
    Fall/Winter 2023


    Subscribe & Save! Within Canada, with free shipping:

    Subscribe & Save! Outside Canada, with free shipping:

    Recent Articles
    June 30, 2023

    On Upstart & Crow
    by Zoe Grams

    March 28, 2023

    Jana Prikryl’s Midwood
    by Andreae Callanan

    March 20, 2023

    Spring Is Here
    by David Mason

    Recent Posts
    • On Upstart & Crow
      by Zoe Grams
    • Jana Prikryl’s Midwood
      by Andreae Callanan
    • Spring Is Here
      by David Mason
    • Where East Meets West
      by J R Patterson
    • Tolu Oloruntoba’s Each One a Furnace
      by Kevin Spenst
    Recent Comments
    • theresa on Don Coles’ A Serious Call
      by David Godkin
    • Mother, Wife, Author and Professor – O'Niel Barrington Blair on Meaghan Strimas
    • Vol. 1 Brooklyn | Afternoon Bites: Yaa Gyasi Interviewed, Justin Torres Nonfiction, Janice Lee on Fritters, Karen Russell, and More on Amy Jones interviewed
      by Brad de Roo
    • Pinball: A Walking Tour by Emily Donaldson – CNQ | Fun With Bonus on Pinball: A Walking Tour
      by Emily Donaldson
    • admin on Interview with Helen Kahn
      by Jason Dickson
    Archives
    • June 2023
    • March 2023
    • February 2023
    • January 2023
    • December 2022
    • November 2022
    • October 2022
    • September 2022
    • August 2022
    • July 2022
    • June 2022
    • April 2022
    • January 2022
    • November 2021
    • June 2021
    • May 2021
    • April 2021
    • February 2021
    • January 2021
    • November 2020
    • August 2020
    • April 2020
    • March 2020
    • February 2020
    • June 2019
    • May 2019
    • April 2019
    • March 2019
    • January 2019
    • November 2018
    • October 2018
    • September 2018
    • August 2018
    • July 2018
    • June 2018
    • May 2018
    • April 2018
    • March 2018
    • February 2018
    • January 2018
    • December 2017
    • November 2017
    • October 2017
    • September 2017
    • August 2017
    • July 2017
    • June 2017
    • May 2017
    • April 2017
    • March 2017
    • February 2017
    • January 2017
    • December 2016
    • November 2016
    • October 2016
    • September 2016
    • August 2016
    • July 2016
    • June 2016
    • May 2016
    • April 2016
    • March 2016
    • February 2016
    • December 2015
    • November 2015
    • July 2015
    • June 2015
    • May 2015
    • April 2015
    • March 2015
    • February 2015
    • January 2015
    • December 2014
    • November 2014
    • October 2014
    • September 2014
    • July 2014
    • May 2014
    • February 2014
    Categories
    • Archives
    • Blog
    • CanLitCrit Essay Contest
    • CNQ Abroad
    • CNQ Timeline
    • Essays
    • Exhumations
    • Features
    • First Reading
    • Interviews
    • Poetry
    • Profiles in Bookselling
    • Rereading
    • Reviews
    • Short Fiction
    • The Antiquarium
    • The Dusty Bookcase
    • The North Wing
    • Uncategorized
    • Used and Rare
    • Web Exclusive
    Meta
    • Log in
    • Entries feed
    • Comments feed
    • WordPress.org
    CNQ: Canadian Notes and Queries
    1686 Ottawa St.
    Windsor, ON
    N8Y 1R1
    Phone: 519-915-3930
    Email: info [at] notesandqueries [dot] ca
    Instagram: @cnandq

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.